|A blueprint created at the time shows the 60+ re-interments, those identified presumably by casket plates and relatives:
- R. Ashton (37 years)
- Beamish adult
- Edna E. Black (11 months, 28 days)
- John Braund (45 years) 1869
- Margaret Budge (31 years) 1851
- Robert Budge
- Baby Gott and Mrs. Conroy
- John Fish (87 years)
- Thomas Gott (40 years)
- Jane Hagerman and a child (23 years) 1852
- Jennie Hall
- James Handyside (24 years)
- Allan Harris (58 years)
- Phoebe Gowen (Mrs. Almon Harris - 32 years) 24 May 1854 (surviving stone)
- Isabella Haw (40 years)
- Helen E. Hayden (2 years, 2 months) 1867
- Mr. Hayward (31 years) - 1845 - and an unknown child
- Sarah Jane Hill (25 years) 1857
- Mr. Howell 1850
- Unknown Howell
- S. Johnston 1871
- Mary Florence Lapp (1 year, 19 days) - 1873 - and mother
- W.E. Lapp (18 years)
- Mary Libby (5 years)
- Stephen Lonsdale (59 years) 1861
- Mr. Milligan
- Sarah Murkly
- John Pigeon (23 years) 1870
- June Quibble (19 years)
- A. Raymond (82 years) 1861
- Sarah A. Rosevere (33 years) 1871 (surviving stone)
- Caroline M. Russell (20 years) 1864
- Margaret Turk (78 years) 1857
- Mrs. Julia Wade (56 years) 1852
- Ralph Wade (70 years)
- Mary Whitt (21 years) 1859 (surviving stone)
- Adult Woodhouse and Babs and Gertrude Sanders
In addition to the above, 11 adults, 1 male, 3 mothers, 6 children, and 2 babies are listed as unknown. (I suspect one of the unknown children to be my great-granduncle, John Thomas Skitch, who died in 1855 at the age of 8 while cleaning a well.) A stone was erected to their memory and the three stones placed within the site.
On 1 October 1931, County Court Judge Lawrence O'Connor issued a certificate attesting
That the owner of the above Cemetery, namely the United Church at Port Hope, has satisfied me, that said owner has removed from the said Cemetery and re-interred in the Port Hope Union Cemetery, which is a Cemetery in the same, or adjacent Municipality, as provided in the Cemetery Act, all the remains which, with the exercise of reasonable diligence it (the said owner) has been able to find buried in such Wesleyan Methodist Church Cemetery in Port Hope.
It is now evident that the Judge was sadly in error. Over the past seventy years, there has been controversy as to whether all remains had truly been cleared, with recurring stories of students and neighbours periodically finding bones. The controversy ended with the 2001 closure of the school and subsequent purchase of the site for redevelopment - the school as condominiums and the playground as five building lots.
In the middle of May 2002, during the construction of a stone retaining wall at the west end of the former playground, a number of remains were found and a team of archaeologists called in. Construction was halted for three months until permission was given for the disinterment of the remains of some thirty individuals - and a number of comingled - which were sent to Trent University for examination and study. Among those disinterred:
- Charles Jacob Mitchell (child) 20 Nov 1867, s/o Christopher and Hannah
- Martha J. Mitchell (9) 1867, d/o Christopher
- Mary Priscilla Mitchell (infant) 29 Nov 1867, d/o Christopher
- Francis Chester Mitchell (6) 25 Nov 1867, s/o Christopher (Although there's no available record for the cause of death of these children within such a short period, early Ontario was subjected to a number of diseases and epidemics that often decimated a community: cholera - 1832, 1834, 1837; ague - 1838 (a third of the population of Lindsay, Ontario); influenza - 1847-'48, 1850-'51, 1857-'59, 1873-'75; as well as periodic outbreaks of smallpox, measles and black diphtheria.)
- Based on a nearby stone, Hannah (Rose) Cunning (16 Jul 1849:Gaspe, Quebec-15 Jul 1871:Port Hope) w/o Abner; m/o Arthur Stillman(b1866), William Angus(b 07 May 1868) and Frederick Louis(b1870). Abner remarried (11 Dec 1872) Emily Rose, a younger sister of Hannah. There were apparently no further children. Abner and Emily are buried in the Toronto Necropolis. (Info: Marian Wight)
- J.? Saga(r)? (8)
- Elizabeth Ogley (13) 03 Jan 1873. She was the d/o John and Delila. In the 1871 Hope Township census returns, she was living with the Thomas Halleran family, with the notation, "No other home".
- Flossy Bayley (5)
- Martha Alice Williams (4 months, 16 days) 12 Oct 1868
Two further sets of remains were discovered near an adjoining lane in the southeast corner, but the weather prohibited removal until the following spring. Those, and eight others were removed by the middle of June, 2003. Three casket plaques were found, identifying:
- C.J. Ryan (17) 1865
- B. Allcott (33), with a child
- 27-year-old teacher, US-born Cynthia McGaffey 1864. According to the 1861 Port Hope census returns, she was living with her widowed mother, Catherine (45) and brothers George (16), Edgar (6) and Ernest (4).
In the middle of July, two last sets of remains were discovered and removed. All were taken to Trent University. Future ancient DNA and isotope testing are planned which hopefully will provide us with more detailed information on the daily life of Port Hope's early pioneers.
At the end of August 2004, the remains were reburied in the memorial plot at Union Cemetery. A public memorial service was held on 25 September, when the last of the remains - believed to be of Hannah (Rose) Cunning - were re-interred, with over twenty of her descendants from as far away as British Columbia, present for the occasion. On a delightful autumn day, a project begun seventy-three years earlier had been brought to a close.
Hanna's re-interment was covered by the 29 Sep 2004 Northumberland News.